We study 6,4 mergers and acquisitions announced between 1980 and 2012, and find that high itp ratios are on average indicative of investor overreaction to the positive news implied by the announcement. Overreaction and underreaction on the bucharest stock exchange. Pdf shortterm overreaction, underreaction and efficient. The overreaction hypothesis hypothesis 1 postulates currency market participants respond too strongly to new information and subsequently revise their estimates of currency value. This is not lost on behavioral finance researchers who acknowledge the issue. Overreaction is an emotional response to news about a security that is generally led either by greed or fear and pushes the price artificially high or low. According to the efficient market hypothesis emh of fama 1970 investors response to new information, plays the main role in degrees of the securities market efficiency. Unsophisticated arbitrageurs and market efficiency.
Industrybased overreaction and underreaction in malaysia iii declaration we hereby declare that. Subscribe to this fee journal for more curated articles on this topic. Market efficiency, longterm returns, and behavioral finance. Vanita tripathi and shalini aggerwal revealed the presence of statistically significant but asymmetric overreaction in indian stock market considering overreaction in. The findings suggest the market underreacts to the content of news articles. Underreaction and overreaction are not caused by different groups of investors. Underreaction, overreaction, and dynamic autocorrelation. Introduction one of the most disputed principles of fama 1970 efficient market hypothesis emh states that prices of. Among them, the phenomena of overreaction and underreaction, inspired by cognitive psychology studies, are one of the most important challenges to market efficiency, and helped to build the foundations of behavioral finance. This study examines individual commodity futures price reaction to large one day price changes, or shocks. Underreaction, overreaction, and dynamic autocorrelation of stock returns hongye guo december 16, 2019 abstract i document that in the us, the aggregate monthly stock returns correlate positively with past returns 23 of the time, and negatively of the time. Shortterm overreaction, underreaction and efficient reaction. Underreaction definition of underreaction by the free.
If the investors response is quick, the market moves toward the efficiency and. Stock market overreaction underreaction implies that 1the american university in cairo, egypt. In particular, the fraction of successfully acquired target firms is. I thank ryan ball, abhijit barua, marcus burger aaa discussant, william cready, r. Among these socalled market efficiency anomalies is the issue of stock market overreaction.
During a market overreaction or underreaction, investors who have insight on what the right direction of movement should be can make abnormal returns on a risk adjusted basis by designing trading strategies consistent with the longrun reversal of the stock price to its true intrinsic value. Overreaction, underreaction, speed of adjustment price, market efficiently. Stock market volatility and impact of a good or bad news. Markets can be efficient even if stock prices exhibit. Efficiency, overreaction and underreaction in stock. In particular, hs information transmission model cannot explain the drift pattern. Behavioral models many empirical works have documented market over or underreaction, which cannot be explained by the efficient market hypothesis. A unified theory of underreaction, momentum trading and overreaction in asset markets.
Overreaction for losers, underreaction for winners march 17, 2008. Overreaction and underreaction on the bucharest stock. Analysts responsiveness and market underreaction to. Market efficiency survives the challenge from the literature on longterm return anomalies. A behavioristic study on overreaction and underreaction. Numerous theories against the efficient market hypothesis fama, 1978, have. The meanadjusted abnormal return model suggests that investors in 6 of the 18 commodity futures, examined in this study, either underreact or overreact to positive surprises. Overreaction and underreaction evidence for the portuguese stock market. These results are consistent with mispricing overreaction to events prior to the surprise, and a corrective price movement after the surprise is consistent with extant research on underreaction. The mispricingcorrection hypothesis explains the superior returns of contrarian strategies noted here and elsewhere in the literature.
Underreaction to news in the us stock market quarterly. We also find that actual global crisis caused significant changes in the investors reactions to the shocks. Overreaction to merger and acquisition announcements. One such anomaly of interest to academic scholars involves the stock market over underreaction hypothesis. Depending on the horizons taken into consideration and on the nature of the shocks we find evidences for the efficient market hypothesis, overreaction hypothesis and the underreaction hypothesis. Markets can be efficient even if many market participants are quite irrational.
Pdf overreaction and underreaction on the bucharest. Efficient markets, overreaction hypothesis, underreaction hypothesis, romanian capital market jel classification. Overreaction explained in a minute behavioural finance. The underreaction is not constrained to small stocks, low analystcoverage stocks, low institutional ownership, or loser stocks. More specifically, we study the directional and magnitude effects associated with abnormal market reaction. Efficiency, overreaction and underreaction in stock markets. The emh, which is a core assumption in classical finance, states that prices should fully reflect all public information available to the market, and. Empirical evidence from the egyptian stock exchange master of science in finance the american university in cairo cairo, egypt submitted to the faculty of the school of business the american university in cairo in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of. Irrational behavior of investors which is inconsistent with the efficient market hypothesis fama, 1970 the resulting overreaction or underreaction.
Responding to these empirical findings, barberis et al. A market hypothesis stating that investors and traders react disproportionately to new information about a given security. Market underreaction to open market share repurchases david ikenberry, josef lakonishoktb, theo vermaelencqd. This is not lost on behavioral finance researchers who acknowledge the. Local stock market and the global financial crisis of. Overreaction and underreaction in the foreign exchange market. Stein abstract we model a market populated by two groups of boundedly rational agents. However, if anomalies arise due to unsophisticated investors behavioral biases, then these same biases can also apply to unsophisticated arbitrageurs and thereby disrupt the arbitrage process. Although we examine the issue of overreaction effect, the focus of our paper is investigating the returns behavior of the stocks rather than finding proof or disproof of the efficiency hypothesis. Three competing hypotheses are initially applied to extreme, 1day exchange rate fluctuations.
Market efficiency, market anomalies, causes, evidences and some behavioural aspects of market anomalies. We examine shortterm investor reaction to extreme events in the uk equity market for the period 1989 to 2004 and find that the market reaction to shocks for large capitalization stock portfolios is consistent with the efficient market hypothesis. Market efficiency, overreaction, underreaction, behavioural finance introduction seasonality in stock prices, excess volatility, price earnings ratio anomaly etc. A unified theory of underreaction, momentum trading and. Among them, the phenomena of overreaction and underreaction, inspired by cognitive psychology studies, are one of the most important challenges to market efficiency, and helped to. The findings also suggest the tone of news articles is different from sentiment which is assumed to have no permanent impact on stock prices. Empirical challenges of the efficient market hypothesis. A unified theory of underreaction, momentum trading, and overreaction in asset markets harrison hong and jeremy c. Empirical study on overreaction and underreaction in. Following the standard scientific rule, market efficiency can only be replaced by a better model. A market is said to be efficient if expectations and consequently prices, correctly incorporates all information available. This will cause the securitys price to change dramatically. A unified theory of underreaction, momentum trading, and. Prior research has documented that arbitrage activity significantly reduces or eliminates stock market anomalies.
It is interesting that two of the three approaches recommend that investors pay careful attention to human behavior. Efficient market hypothesis, underreaction, overreaction. The work proves that market overreaction followed by initial underreaction results in contrarian profits. The directional effect is the phenomenon that an extreme price movement will be followed by a price movement in the opposite overreaction hypothesis or same underreaction hypothesis direction. Even in market efficiency, longterm returns and behavioral finance 1998, fama wrote that although the behavioral finance literature does not clearly lean towards either side i. The remaining of the paper is organized as follows. In an efficient market, the stock should no longer be undervalued after the announcement, thus eliminating the motivation to undertake the repurchase. The weakform efficient market hypothesis holds that stock returns cannot be predicted. We then comprehensively compare the intensities of the firstorder autocorrelation by using wald coefficients tests. Guo, hongye, underreaction, overreaction, and dynamic autocorrelation of stock returns november 16, 2019.
Pdf efficient market hypothesis states that financial markets react instantaneous and unbiased to new information. Overreaction for losers, underreaction for winners ferhat akbas, emre kocatulum, and sorin m. Using the information adjusted noise model iamn developed ramiah and davidson 2007 we test whether there is noise trader risk, overreaction, underreaction and ipe on the shenzhen a share market. It also detects underreaction patterns in 8 commodity future prices following negative surprises. While the two arms of correlation are separately strong, they cancel with each.
Market underreaction to open market share repurchases. The psychology of underreaction and overreaction ham and david dodd 1934. Stock overreaction and the arrival of new information in an efficient market, stock price is expected to adjust rapidly and accurately to its new equilibrium level upon arrival of new information. Noise trading, underreaction, overreaction and information. Analysts responsiveness and market underreaction to earnings announcements abstract this study shows that analysts vary significantly in their responsiveness to earnings announcements, where responsiveness is defined as promptness of analysts first forecast revisions for the next quarter since the prior quarterly earnings announcements. The empirical and theoretical challenge since the early 1960s. Consistent with the market efficiency hypothesis that the anomalies are chance results, apparent overreaction to information is about as common as underreaction, and postevent continuation of preevent abnormal returns is about as frequent as postevent reversal.
393 1393 1504 275 218 1115 283 1416 1116 1049 307 1424 1331 1079 231 1508 1091 1542 888 264 172 276 911 418 116 1315 109 32 1285 199 186 220 1157 646 166 1015 410 703 759